Crowe Breaks Down During Testimony

Crowe Was 'Scared, Wanted To Go Home'

Richard-Tuite-Trial-2853148.jpg

Richard Tuite Trial

Michael-Crowe-crying-3002111.jpg

Michael Crowe crying

Posted: 04/14/2004
Last Updated: 3329 days ago

Michael Crowe faced a difficult day in court Tuesday as he relived police interrogations from six years ago, 10News reported.

Crowe, who was originally charged with the murder of his sister, Stephanie Crowe, began testifying for the prosecution Monday in its rebuttal case on what would have been the victim's 19th birthday.

Now 20, Crowe and the jury watched three hours of videotaped police interrogations.

The prosecution interrupted the tape for live questioning in court.

Crowe's friends Josh Treadway and Aaron Houser were also originally charged with the murder. The three were arrested and charged based largely on statements Crowe and Treadway gave to Escondido police detectives during long interrogations. Prosecutors have since said that the statements were coerced.

During his interrogation, Crowe, then 14, repeatedly said he couldn't remember anything about the killing. Then, after hours of questioning, he expressed hatred for his sister and -- without providing details -- agreed with detectives that he killed her.

Treadway gave detectives a detailed description of how he acted as a lookout as Houser and Michael Crowe carried out the murder.

A judge in 1999 ruled that Crowe's statements and most of Treadway's were coerced and inadmissible at trial.

Judge Frederic Link allowed Tuite's attorneys to play the tapes in the defense's effort to show that the boys did it.

Crowe talked about the interrogations Tuesday. He testified that he and his sister, Shannon, were taken to the Escondido police station for questioning about two hours after Stephanie was found dead.

He said he was questioned about four different times that day by detectives without his parents present.

Crowe also said he told detectives he was scared and wanted to go home to his family.

"I was scared. I just didn't know what was going on. I just wanted to be with my family and I didn't know why I couldn't be," Crowe told the jury.

In earlier testimony, Crowe recalled the chain of events the night Stephanie was murdered.

He said he and Stephanie were watching TV the night of Jan. 20, 1998, then each retired to their bedrooms around 9:30 p.m.

Crowe said he was awakened by pounding, which sounded like it was coming from a laundry room door that the Crowes used as a front door.

The witness told Deputy Attorney General James Dutton that he didn't get up because the noise stopped, and he figured someone answered the door.

Crowe testified that he woke up around 4:30 a.m. with a headache and went to the kitchen to get some aspirin and a glass of milk.

A medical examiner said the victim was killed sometime after midnight and her body would have been partially extending into the hallway where Michael Crowe walked, but he testified that he saw nothing.

The witness said he woke up to loud voices outside his room between 6 a.m. and 6:30 a.m., went into the hallway and saw his mother on top of Stephanie and his father running around trying to find a phone.

"I saw my mom on top of my sister Stephanie on the ground and my dad was running back and forth in the hallway. I didn't get a good look at Stephanie, just a glimpse. I looked away because I saw blood and when I see blood I get sick," Crowe told the jury.

Escondido police testified that Michael was sitting by himself and acting differently than other family members in the hours after Stephanie's body was discovered.

Tuite was charged two years ago when the victim's blood was discovered on a red sweatshirt Tuite had on the night of the killing.

He was seen in the Crowe neighborhood the night of the killing knocking on doors, looking in windows and asking for a friend named "Tracy."

Prosecutors also said the defendant liked to carry knives.

Previous Stories:

Copyright Copyright 2004 by TheSanDiegoChannel.com. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.


San Diego , CA  
62° Mostly cloudy

Stay Connected

Send us a News Tip Send us a News Tip
Tablet & iPhone/Android Apps Mobile/Tablet Apps
Twitter Twitter
Facebook Facebook
YouTube YouTube
SanDiegoLaw.tv SanDiegoLaw.tv