Document trail: Melvin Chris Estes

EstesMugshot_1351538673795.jpg

Posted: 10/29/2012
Last Updated: 233 days ago

It wasn’t just Scout victims whose lives were affected. Sometimes, whole families were devastated.

Veronica Akins, of Bishop Hills, Texas, said that’s what happened when her 13-year-old son was molested by Scout leader Melvin Christopher Estes in the late 1980s. Estes tried to fondle him in the bathroom of the church where the troop met, according to the victim’s deposition. Another time, Estes invited him into his bedroom to look at pornographic magazines. He started massaging the boy and tried to take off his pants.

Estes was convicted in 1989 of three counts of aggravated sexual assault and one count of indecency with a child. One of the four victims was Akins’ son, Chance Curtis. Estes was sentenced to 20 years in prison.

Akins sued the Boy Scouts of America and the local council, claiming they were negligent in allowing Estes to remain a Scout leader. She alleged that they knew he’d been accused of molestation previously, but ignored it and gave him his own troop.

The Boy Scouts argued that Estes was quickly suspended after local officials learned of molestation allegations. The Scouts maintained that while they chartered community-based organizations that sponsored troops, they didn’t supervise them or choose Scout leaders.

The mother of four appealed her case all the way to the Texas Supreme Court. It ruled in 1996 that the national organization could not be held responsible, but that the local council -- which recommended Estes for the scoutmaster’s job -- could. Akins later agreed to an undisclosed settlement.

Akins said her son, now 37, has never been the same.
 

Copyright 2012 Scripps Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.


Full Series

  1. Part 1 - Inside the Files

    Part 1 - Inside the Files

    Our exclusive look into the Boy Scouts confidential files – 30,000 documents, 10 journalists, 6 months of research. Our investigation reveals scouts’ pleas for help being ignored while some scout leaders were promised confidentiality.

  2. Part 2 - Systemic Failures

    Part 2 - Systemic Failures

    The Scripps National Investigative Team tracks systemic problems within the Boy Scouts of America, including poor background checks, and suspected molesters moving from troop to troop. More of our exclusive interview with the leader of BSA.

  3. Part 3 - Scouts Today

    Part 3 - Scouts Today

    After revelations of abuse within the Boy Scouts of America, how has the organization and its policies changed, and are changes working? You’ll hear different sides. Plus, a one-time abused scout has to decide whether scouting is right for his sons.

Extended Interviews

  1. Exclusive video interview: Patrick Boyle

    Exclusive video interview: Patrick Boyle

    Boyle wrote “Scout’s Honor,” a 1994 book examining child sexual abuse in the Boy Scouts of America.

  2. Video interview: Tom Stewart

    Video interview: Tom Stewart

     

    Former scout Tom Stewart describes years of abuse he suffered as a child, and how he views scouting today as a father.

Related Stories

  1. Expert: Exposing abuses will help kids

    Expert: Exposing abuses will help kids

    Patrick Boyle was the first to publish reports of the Boy Scouts of America's confidential "ineligible volunteers" files, in 1994.  Boyle says the attention these files are now getting will do good for kids.
     
     
  2. Boy Scouts' president official statement

    Boy Scouts' president official statement

    An official response to our investigation from Boy Scouts of America national president Wayne Perry.
     
     

Document Trail

  1. Document trail: William A. Hoefling

    Document trail: William A. Hoefling

    Look at the confidential documents in Hoefling's file. Hoefling was a troop leader near Detroit.

  2. Document trail: Scott A. Herrick

    Document trail: Scott A. Herrick

    Click to view confidential documents in his file. Herrick is currently serving a 95-year sentence.

  3. Document trail: Brian K. Liska

    Document trail: Brian K. Liska

    Examine for yourself: the documents in his confidential files. To this day, Liska said he doesn't know if national Scouting officials approved his application because they were unaware of his past conviction -- or if they knew about it but decided he was fit nonetheless.