Tuite Found Guilty Of Lesser Charge
Tuite Not Guilty Of Murder, Guilty Of Voluntary Manslaughter
POSTED: 11:18 am PDT May 26, 2004
UPDATED: 3:22 pm PDT May 26, 2004
SAN DIEGO -- Richard Tuite was convicted Wednesday of voluntary manslaughter in the 1998 slaying of a 12-year-old girl who was stabbed to death in her bedroom while her family slept in their home.
After eight days of deliberations, a jury acquitted Tuite, 35, of the more serious charges of first- and second-degree murder in the death of Stephanie Crowe. The trial lasted 3-and-a-half months."You people have probably been involved in the most complicated criminal cases I've seen in 37 years... I know this was not an easy case for you," Judge Frederic Link told the jurors after the verdicts were read.Tuite is scheduled to be sentenced on July 29 at 9 a.m.Crowe was found slain in her bedroom on the morning of Jan. 21, 1998. She had been stabbed nine times.Prosecutors initially targeted Stephanie's then-14-year-old brother, Michael, and two of his high school friends. Charges against them were dropped a year later when drops of the girl's blood were found on a shirt Tuite wore the night of the slaying.Defense attorneys, however, argued the shirt was contaminated by police during their investigation and their strategy was centered on the contention that Michael Crowe and his friends, Joshua Treadway and Aaron Houser, were involved in the slaying.Defense lawyer Brad Patton said in closing arguments that Crowe hated his sister and was obsessed with violent video games. He also reminded jurors that he and Treadway confessed to the killing, although authorities later ruled that the confessions from the boys had been coerced during lengthy police interrogations.Assistant Attorney General David Druliner described the defense argument as "utterly ridiculous" and "idiotic." He said the DNA evidence was strong evidence of Tuite's guilt.Neighbors had reported seeing Tuite in the suburban neighborhood around the time of the slaying. Some said he had knocked on doors asking for a young woman named Tracy Nelson. Escondido police briefly questioned Tuite but released him after deciding the habitual drug user and diagnosed schizophrenic was incapable of committing the crime, which required someone to enter Stephanie's room and kill her while five other people were in the home.A month later, Tuite was arrested after two Escondido girls said he followed them off a bus. He was arrested again in March 1998 after trying to break into an Oceanside trailer home and was sentenced to three years in prison.In 2000, he escaped from an Ontario halfway house but was captured and returned to prison. While at a halfway house in 2001, he was returned to prison after being caught with a knife.Shortly before he was to be released from prison in May 2002, he was charged in the girl's slaying.As jury selection for his trial got underway in February, Tuite walked away from the courthouse in downtown San Diego after slipping from his handcuffs during a lunch break. He was captured 4 hours later at a pay phone about 10 miles away.
![]() TUITE MURDER TRIAL |
| Video |
Previous Stories:
- May 25, 2004: Judge Refuses To Make Notes From Tuite Jury Public
- May 24, 2004: Tuite Jury Still Deliberating After Six Days
- May 20, 2004: Still No Verdict In Tuite Murder Trial
- May 20, 2004: Tuite Murder Trial Jurors Back Deliberating
- May 20, 2004: Judge Orders Jury To Continue Deliberations
- May 13, 2004: Jury Starts Deliberating In Tuite Murder Trial
- May 10, 2004: Closing Arguments Begin In Tuite Trial
- May 4, 2004: Both Sides Rest In Tuite Trial
- May 3, 2004: Judge Replaces Juror In Tuite Trial
- April 26, 2004: Tuite Trial: Man Testifies Son Denied Involvement With Murder
- April 22, 2004: Treadway Continues Testimony In Tuite Trial
- April 21, 2004: Teen Once Accused Of Crowe Death Testifies
- April 20, 2004: Crowe's Family Testifies About Sibling's Relationship
- April 19, 2004: Crowe Says He Lied To Police About Killing Sister
- April 15, 2004: Crowe Explains Confession In Sister's Killing
- April 14, 2004: Crowe Breaks Down During Testimony
- April 13, 2004: Michael Crowe Continues To Testify
- April 6, 2004: Blood Stain Expert Testifies In Tuite Trial
- April 2, 2004: Jurors Hear Crowe Say He Doesn't Recall Killing Sister
- March 30, 2004: Jury Hears Teens' Plot To Kill Crowe
- March 29, 2004: Jurors Hear Teen Say Two Friends Killed Stephanie Crowe
- March 25, 2004: Original Lead Investigator Testifies In Tuite Trial
- March 23, 2004: Jurors In Tuite Trial Continue To Watch Interrogations
- March 22, 2004: Tuite's Defense Tries To Create Reasonable Doubt
- March 18, 2004: Defense Calls First Witness In Tuite Trial
- March 17, 2004: Deputies Relive Embarrassing Tuite Escape
- March 16, 2004: Parents Of Murder Victim Testify
- March 15, 2004: DNA Analyst: Crowe's Blood On Tuite's Sweatshirt
- March 12, 2004: Crowe Younger Sister Takes Stand
- March 2, 2004: Examiner: Wounds Didn't Prevent Crowe From Screaming
- March 1, 2004: Girls Say Tuite Followed Them To Escondido
- February 25, 2004: Former Cellmate Testifies Against Tuite
- February 24, 2004: 'Tracy' Testifies In Tuite Trial
- February 20, 2004: Bailiff Fails To Secure Tuite's Cuffs Correctly
- February 19, 2004: Witness: Tuite 'Didn't Look Right' Night Of Murder
- February 18, 2004: Tuite Defense Blames Victim's Brother, Friends
- February 18, 2004: Tuite Murder Trial: Watch Openings Statements
- February 17, 2004: Opening Statements Presented In Tuite Trial
- February 10, 2004: Jurors Sworn In For Tuite Trial
- February 9, 2004: Jury Selected For Tuite Trial
- February 6, 2004: Potential Jurors Questioned On Tuite's Escape
- February 6, 2004: Prosecution Wants Jury To Consider Tuite's Escape
- February 4, 2004: Judge: Tuite Trial To Continue As Planned
- February 3, 2004: Man Allegedly Witnesses Tuite Escape
- February 3, 2004: Accused Murderer Captured After Escape
- February 2, 2004: Jury Selection Begins For Crowe Murder Case
- January 14, 2004: Judge OKs Bloody Undershirt In Tuite Trial
- December 19, 2003: Tuite Trial To Remain In San Diego
- December 12, 2003: New Evidence Revealed In Crowe Murder Case
- September 25, 2003: Judge: Tuite Mentally Competent To Stand Trial
- September 23, 2003: Tuite Competency Trial Begins
- July 16, 2003: Judge: Tuite Must Be Examined By Psychiatrist
- June 9, 2003: Judge Could Reveal Tuite's Troubled Past To Jurors
- March 26, 2003: Tentative Date Set For Tuite Trial
- March 17, 2003: Tuite Pleads Not Guilty To Crowe Murder
- March 4, 2003: Tuite To Stand Trial For Crowe Murder
- February 27, 2003: Teen In Tuite Hearing Can't Explain Knife
- February 26, 2003: Teen Takes Stand In Tuite Hearing
- February 25, 2003: Prosecutors Play 'Confession' Tape In Tuite Hearing
- February 21, 2003: Prosecutors Will Also Show Tapes In Tuite Hearing
- February 20, 2003: Tape: Teen Admits Part In Stephanie Crowe Murder
- February 19, 2003: Will Tuite Stand Trial For Stephanie Crowe's Murder?
- February 14, 2003: Court: Tuite Can Present Evidence Against Crowe's Brother
- February 11, 2003: Tuite Preliminary Hearing On Hold
- February 10, 2003: Tuite Preliminary Hearing Continues
- February 6, 2003: 2nd Day Of Tuite Hearing Under Way
- February 5, 2003: Day 1 Of Tuite Preliminary Hearing Held
- September 19, 2002: Tuite's Preliminary Hearing Set
- August 26, 2002: Tuite Hearing May Come This Fall
- May 22, 2002: Crowe Family Wants Civil Case Sped Up
- May 16, 2002: Tuite Pleads Not Guilty To Crowe Murder
- May 16, 2002: Tuite To Be Arraigned Today
- May 15, 2002: Tuite To Be Charged With Stephanie Crowe's Murder
- May 14, 2002: Arrest Looms In 1998 Child Killing
- July 11, 2001: Crowe Murder Suspect Released From Prison
- May 30, 2001: Man Linked To Crowe Murder Back In Prison
- May 25, 2001: Man Investigated In Crowe Murder To Be Paroled
- November 28, 2000: Transient Suspected Of Escondido Murder Back Behind Bars
Copyright 2004 by 10News.com. The Associated Press contributed to this report. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.





