Jurors Hear Crowe Say He Doesn't Recall Killing Sister
Defense Trying To Create Reasonable Doubt
POSTED: 11:31 am PST April 2, 2004
UPDATED: 11:49 am PST April 2, 2004
SAN DIEGO -- Jurors in the Richard Tuite murder trial heard a 1998 videotaped interrogation Thursday in which a tearful Michael Crowe told detectives he wants to cooperate but doesn't remember killing his sister.
"I don't know how the evidence points to me because I didn't do it," the 14-year-old told Escondido detectives Mark Wrisley and Ralph Claytor during the Jan. 23 interview that year.Michael Crowe told Claytor he doesn't remember moving Stephanie Crowe's body after she was stabbed on her bed."Were you trying to help Stephanie?" Claytor asked."I can't remember anything," Michael responded.The detectives tell the teen he was made of two parts; one good Michael who loves Stephanie and one bad Michael.Maybe the bad Michael killed his sister, Claytor told the teenager."If this is true, I don't even know he exists," Michael Crowe told the detectives.Michael Crowe, (pictured, left, middle), and friends Josh Treadway, (pictured, far left), and Aaron Houser, (pictured, left), were originally charged with killing Stephanie. She was slain the night of Jan. 20, 1998 or early the next day.
Police found no signs of forced entry into the Crowes' rural Escondido home and figured someone there was responsible.But before trial in 1999, a judge threw out most of the police interrogations of Michael Crowe and Treadway, saying they were illegally obtained.Attorneys for Tuite were allowed to show jurors the interrogations in an attempt to convince the panel that the teenagers did it.Prosecutors from the state Attorney General's Office said the boys' statements were coerced. The defense suggests the blood evidence implicating Tuite was accidentally transferred to his shirts.Margaret Decker-Martineau, director of psychological services for the Escondido High School District at the time, testified she counseled Treadway the day after the murder.Michael Crowe and his sister, Shannon, were taken into protective custody on Jan. 21, 1998."(Treadway) asked me how I thought Michael was," Decker-Martineau testified. "He was very distracted."She said she gave Treadway a ride home from school because she was unsure he was aware of his surroundings, especially walking along the road.The psychologist said she met with Treadway, Houser and their mothers at Houser's residence on Jan. 25, 1998, which was Super Bowl Sunday.Decker-Martineau testified that Houser was extremely polite, but she could sense he didn't want her there.She said Treadway was still anxious and asked a question "completely out of the blue.""He said, 'You don't think they think we had anything to do with this, do you?'" the psychologist testified.Michael Crowe was arrested Jan. 24, 1998.The case against the boys was dismissed when the victim's blood was found on a red sweatshirt Tuite had on the night of the murder.Tiny smears of Stephanie's blood were later found on a white T-shirt Tuite had on under the sweatshirt.Tuite was charged two years ago, after the murder investigation was turned over to the San Diego County Sheriff's Department.Prosecutors said the diagnosed schizophrenic was in the area of the Crowe residence the night of the murder, asking for a friend named "Tracy."Evidence also has been presented that the defendant liked to carry a knife.
| Video |
Police found no signs of forced entry into the Crowes' rural Escondido home and figured someone there was responsible.But before trial in 1999, a judge threw out most of the police interrogations of Michael Crowe and Treadway, saying they were illegally obtained.Attorneys for Tuite were allowed to show jurors the interrogations in an attempt to convince the panel that the teenagers did it.Prosecutors from the state Attorney General's Office said the boys' statements were coerced. The defense suggests the blood evidence implicating Tuite was accidentally transferred to his shirts.Margaret Decker-Martineau, director of psychological services for the Escondido High School District at the time, testified she counseled Treadway the day after the murder.Michael Crowe and his sister, Shannon, were taken into protective custody on Jan. 21, 1998."(Treadway) asked me how I thought Michael was," Decker-Martineau testified. "He was very distracted."She said she gave Treadway a ride home from school because she was unsure he was aware of his surroundings, especially walking along the road.The psychologist said she met with Treadway, Houser and their mothers at Houser's residence on Jan. 25, 1998, which was Super Bowl Sunday.Decker-Martineau testified that Houser was extremely polite, but she could sense he didn't want her there.She said Treadway was still anxious and asked a question "completely out of the blue.""He said, 'You don't think they think we had anything to do with this, do you?'" the psychologist testified.Michael Crowe was arrested Jan. 24, 1998.The case against the boys was dismissed when the victim's blood was found on a red sweatshirt Tuite had on the night of the murder.Tiny smears of Stephanie's blood were later found on a white T-shirt Tuite had on under the sweatshirt.Tuite was charged two years ago, after the murder investigation was turned over to the San Diego County Sheriff's Department.Prosecutors said the diagnosed schizophrenic was in the area of the Crowe residence the night of the murder, asking for a friend named "Tracy."Evidence also has been presented that the defendant liked to carry a knife.
Previous Stories:
- March 30, 2004: Jury Hears Teens' Plot To Kill Crowe
- March 29, 2004: Jurors Hear Teen Say Two Friends Killed Stephanie Crowe
- March 25, 2004: Original Lead Investigator Testifies In Tuite Trial
- March 23, 2004: Jurors In Tuite Trial Continue To Watch Interrogations
- March 22, 2004: Tuite's Defense Tries To Create Reasonable Doubt
- March 18, 2004: Defense Calls First Witness In Tuite Trial
- March 17, 2004: Deputies Relive Embarrassing Tuite Escape
- March 16, 2004: Parents Of Murder Victim Testify
- March 15, 2004: DNA Analyst: Crowe's Blood On Tuite's Sweatshirt
- March 12, 2004: Crowe Younger Sister Takes Stand
- March 2, 2004: Examiner: Wounds Didn't Prevent Crowe From Screaming
- March 1, 2004: Girls Say Tuite Followed Them To Escondido
- February 25, 2004: Former Cellmate Testifies Against Tuite
- February 24, 2004: 'Tracy' Testifies In Tuite Trial
- February 20, 2004: Bailiff Fails To Secure Tuite's Cuffs Correctly
- February 19, 2004: Witness: Tuite 'Didn't Look Right' Night Of Murder
- February 18, 2004: Tuite Defense Blames Victim's Brother, Friends
- February 18, 2004: Tuite Murder Trial: Watch Openings Statements
- February 17, 2004: Opening Statements Presented In Tuite Trial
- February 10, 2004: Jurors Sworn In For Tuite Trial
- February 9, 2004: Jury Selected For Tuite Trial
- February 6, 2004: Potential Jurors Questioned On Tuite's Escape
- February 6, 2004: Prosecution Wants Jury To Consider Tuite's Escape
- February 4, 2004: Judge: Tuite Trial To Continue As Planned
- February 3, 2004: Man Allegedly Witnesses Tuite Escape
- February 3, 2004: Accused Murderer Captured After Escape
- February 2, 2004: Jury Selection Begins For Crowe Murder Case
- January 14, 2004: Judge OKs Bloody Undershirt In Tuite Trial
- December 19, 2003: Tuite Trial To Remain In San Diego
- December 12, 2003: New Evidence Revealed In Crowe Murder Case
- September 25, 2003: Judge: Tuite Mentally Competent To Stand Trial
- September 23, 2003: Tuite Competency Trial Begins
- July 16, 2003: Judge: Tuite Must Be Examined By Psychiatrist
- June 9, 2003: Judge Could Reveal Tuite's Troubled Past To Jurors
- March 26, 2003: Tentative Date Set For Tuite Trial
- March 17, 2003: Tuite Pleads Not Guilty To Crowe Murder
- March 4, 2003: Tuite To Stand Trial For Crowe Murder
- February 27, 2003: Teen In Tuite Hearing Can't Explain Knife
- February 26, 2003: Teen Takes Stand In Tuite Hearing
- February 25, 2003: Prosecutors Play 'Confession' Tape In Tuite Hearing
- February 21, 2003: Prosecutors Will Also Show Tapes In Tuite Hearing
- February 20, 2003: Tape: Teen Admits Part In Stephanie Crowe Murder
- February 19, 2003: Will Tuite Stand Trial For Stephanie Crowe's Murder?
- February 14, 2003: Court: Tuite Can Present Evidence Against Crowe's Brother
- February 11, 2003: Tuite Preliminary Hearing On Hold
- February 10, 2003: Tuite Preliminary Hearing Continues
- February 6, 2003: 2nd Day Of Tuite Hearing Under Way
- February 5, 2003: Day 1 Of Tuite Preliminary Hearing Held
- September 19, 2002: Tuite's Preliminary Hearing Set
- August 26, 2002: Tuite Hearing May Come This Fall
- May 22, 2002: Crowe Family Wants Civil Case Sped Up
- May 16, 2002: Tuite Pleads Not Guilty To Crowe Murder
- May 16, 2002: Tuite To Be Arraigned Today
- May 15, 2002: Tuite To Be Charged With Stephanie Crowe's Murder
- May 14, 2002: Arrest Looms In 1998 Child Killing
- July 11, 2001: Crowe Murder Suspect Released From Prison
- May 30, 2001: Man Linked To Crowe Murder Back In Prison
- May 25, 2001: Man Investigated In Crowe Murder To Be Paroled
- November 28, 2000: Transient Suspected Of Escondido Murder Back Behind Bars
Copyright 2004 by TheSanDiegoChannel.com. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.




