Judge: Tuite Must Be Examined By Psychiatrist
Accused Killer Diagnosed With Schizophrenia
POSTED: 12:23 p.m. PDT July 16, 2003
UPDATED: 12:31 p.m. PDT July 16, 2003
SAN DIEGO -- The accused killer of 12-year-old Stephanie Crowe will be examined by a court-appointed psychiatrist to determine if he is mentally competent to assist his lawyers in his murder trial, a judge ruled Wednesday.
Judge Frederic Link's decision to grant the defense request for an examination means Tuite's scheduled Sept. 8 trial date is off.
Tuite, (pictured, left), a transient diagnosed with schizophrenia, is accused of sneaking into the youngster's rural Escondido home and stabbing her to death the night of Jan. 20, 1998.
The girl's body was discovered in her bedroom the next morning by family members, who said they heard nothing during the night.
Tuite, 33, will return to court Aug. 6, when a ruling is expected on whether he understands the charges against him and can help his attorneys prepare for what is expected to be a trial of up to four months in length.
Link said it may be necessary to conduct a nonjury trial to determine whether Tuite is mentally competent to go to trial.
If the defendant is found competent and criminal proceedings are reinstated, trial would be set for Feb. 2, the judge said.
Defense attorney Brad Patton said there was "no conceivable way" that he and attorney William Fletcher would be ready for trial in September, given the ongoing investigation by authorities.
Patton said he might also file a motion to move the trial out of San Diego.
Tuite was seen in the area of the Crowe residence the night before the girl's murder, asking for an old friend named Tracy.
Michael Crowe, the victim's 14-year-old brother, and two friends were originally charged with her killing. But charges were dropped in 1999 when a DNA test revealed the victim's blood on a shirt that Tuite wore the night of the murder.
At a preliminary hearing earlier this year, Tuite's lawyers presented evidence that they say pointed to Michael Crowe, Joshua Treadway and Aaron Houser as the real killers.
The case was turned over to the San Diego County Sheriff's Department and the state Attorney General's Office three years ago.
Special Assistant Attorney General David Druliner said Escondido detectives made "multiple assumptions" early on, such as the murder was an inside job.
The prosecutor said detectives threatened and mistreated Treadway during more than 25 hours of interrogation over a three-day period, causing the teen to lie and implicate his friends in the slaying.
Patton said earlier that he will present evidence at trial that the blood specks found on Tuite's shirt could have been caused by contamination.
Link ruled last month that Tuite's attorneys could use the incriminating statements made by Michael Crowe and Treadway at trial, despite the coercive tactics used by Escondido detectives and other police officers.
Judge Frederic Link's decision to grant the defense request for an examination means Tuite's scheduled Sept. 8 trial date is off.
Tuite, (pictured, left), a transient diagnosed with schizophrenia, is accused of sneaking into the youngster's rural Escondido home and stabbing her to death the night of Jan. 20, 1998.
The girl's body was discovered in her bedroom the next morning by family members, who said they heard nothing during the night.
Tuite, 33, will return to court Aug. 6, when a ruling is expected on whether he understands the charges against him and can help his attorneys prepare for what is expected to be a trial of up to four months in length.
Link said it may be necessary to conduct a nonjury trial to determine whether Tuite is mentally competent to go to trial.
If the defendant is found competent and criminal proceedings are reinstated, trial would be set for Feb. 2, the judge said.
Defense attorney Brad Patton said there was "no conceivable way" that he and attorney William Fletcher would be ready for trial in September, given the ongoing investigation by authorities.
Patton said he might also file a motion to move the trial out of San Diego.
Tuite was seen in the area of the Crowe residence the night before the girl's murder, asking for an old friend named Tracy.
Michael Crowe, the victim's 14-year-old brother, and two friends were originally charged with her killing. But charges were dropped in 1999 when a DNA test revealed the victim's blood on a shirt that Tuite wore the night of the murder.
At a preliminary hearing earlier this year, Tuite's lawyers presented evidence that they say pointed to Michael Crowe, Joshua Treadway and Aaron Houser as the real killers.
The case was turned over to the San Diego County Sheriff's Department and the state Attorney General's Office three years ago.
Special Assistant Attorney General David Druliner said Escondido detectives made "multiple assumptions" early on, such as the murder was an inside job.
The prosecutor said detectives threatened and mistreated Treadway during more than 25 hours of interrogation over a three-day period, causing the teen to lie and implicate his friends in the slaying.
Patton said earlier that he will present evidence at trial that the blood specks found on Tuite's shirt could have been caused by contamination.
Link ruled last month that Tuite's attorneys could use the incriminating statements made by Michael Crowe and Treadway at trial, despite the coercive tactics used by Escondido detectives and other police officers.
Previous Stories:
- June 9, 2003: Judge Could Reveal Tuite's Troubled Past To Jurors
- March 26, 2003: Tentative Date Set For Tuite Trial
- March 17, 2003: Tuite Pleads Not Guilty To Crowe Murder
- March 4, 2003: Tuite To Stand Trial For Crowe Murder
- February 27, 2003: Teen In Tuite Hearing Can't Explain Knife
- February 26, 2003: Teen Takes Stand In Tuite Hearing
- February 25, 2003: Prosecutors Play 'Confession' Tape In Tuite Hearing
- February 21, 2003: Prosecutors Will Also Show Tapes In Tuite Hearing
- February 20, 2003: Tape: Teen Admits Part In Stephanie Crowe Murder
- February 19, 2003: Will Tuite Stand Trial For Stephanie Crowe's Murder?
- February 14, 2003: Court: Tuite Can Present Evidence Against Crowe's Brother
- February 11, 2003: Tuite Preliminary Hearing On Hold
- February 10, 2003: Tuite Preliminary Hearing Continues
- February 6, 2003: 2nd Day Of Tuite Hearing Under Way
- February 5, 2003: Day 1 Of Tuite Preliminary Hearing Held
- September 19, 2002: Tuite's Preliminary Hearing Set
- August 26, 2002: Tuite Hearing May Come This Fall
- May 22, 2002: Crowe Family Wants Civil Case Sped Up
- May 16, 2002: Tuite Pleads Not Guilty To Crowe Murder
- May 16, 2002: Tuite To Be Arraigned Today
- May 15, 2002: Tuite To Be Charged With Stephanie Crowe's Murder
- May 14, 2002: Arrest Looms In 1998 Child Killing
- July 11, 2001: Crowe Murder Suspect Released From Prison
Copyright 2004 by TheSanDiegoChannel.com. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.



