Westerfield Lawyers Gearing For Sentence Fight
Westerfield Kidnapped, Murdered Danielle Van Dam
POSTED: 2:22 pm PDT August 22, 2002
UPDATED: 5:40 pm PDT August 22, 2002
SAN DIEGO -- Attorneys in the David Westerfield case prepared Thursday for a fight over what character evidence can be presented to a jury that must recommend whether he is put to death or spends the rest of his life in prison.
Westerfield, 50, was convicted of kidnapping and killing 7-year-old Danielle van Dam more than six months ago.Friday, defense attorney Steven Feldman will ask Judge William Mudd to preview what evidence prosecutors plan to present involving violence or use of force, once the penalty phase gets under way Wednesday.
Before they were chosen, the jurors in the Westerfield case said they could impose the death penalty under the right circumstances. But whether they can actually vote for death is another matter, according to experts."It's much more complicated than if you had someone with a long past history of criminal behavior, particularly violent crime," Thomas Jefferson School of Law professor David Steinberg told 10News. "That's what the defense is going to argue. This is not a serial killer. This is a guy who, for whatever reason, just lost it one night."Feldman told the judge he may call as many as 10 out-of-state witnesses in the penalty phase.Vincent Garcia, a supervising attorney for the Alternate Public Defender's Office, said jurors will hear testimony about Westerfield's childhood, which may explain why he committed the crimes."We want to know as much as we can about the person whose life hangs in the balance," said Garcia, who is not involved in the Westerfield case. "When we consider the ultimate penalty, we as a system prefer to know more about a defendant than not."Another observer, defense attorney David Bartick, said jurors will go through a "weighing process" as they consider the factors justifying the death penalty and the factors justifying life behind bars.The prosecution's case will include testimony from parents, friends and classmates who knew Danielle, experts said."The prosecution is really going to play up who Danielle van Dam was," said alternate Public Defender Jesse Gilbert. "They're clearly going to rely on the jury's emotions, given who the victim was. Frankly, that's why (prosecutors) are going for the death penalty."Factors to be considered in the penalty phase include the defendant's level of intoxication -- Westerfield was said to have been drunk the night before Danielle was discovered missing on Feb. 2 -- possible mental disorders and lack of criminal record, experts said."If the jury has any lingering doubts, this is where it's going to play out," said former prosecutor Mike Still.Westerfield, who lived two doors from the van Dam family in Sabre Springs, was convicted of murder, kidnapping, possession of child pornography and a special circumstance allegation that the murder happened during a kidnapping.Prosecutors couldn't prove that Danielle was sexually assaulted because her body was in state of advanced decomposition when it was found Feb. 27.In presenting evidence on the pornography found in Westerfield's home office, prosecutors said it showed what his motive had been for kidnapping the child.Some experts predict that Westerfield's attorneys will appeal the convictions because Mudd refused to sequester the jury during deliberations to try to shield them from intense publicity.A gag order on all participants in the trial remains in place.If Westerfield is sentenced to death, a motion for a new trial would immediately be filed. If that were denied, the case would be appealed to the state Supreme Court.
![]() WESTERFIELD TRIAL DANIELLE VAN DAM 1994-2002 E-mail: daniellevandam @yahoo.com Send mail to: P.O. Box 501515 San Diego, 92150 |
| Video |
Previous Stories:
- August 21, 2002: David Westerfield Found Guilty On All Counts
- August 21, 2002: San Diegans React To Westerfield Verdict
- August 20, 2002: Westerfield Jury Still Talking It Out
- August 20, 2002: Westerfield Jury Enters Day 9
- August 19, 2002: Westerfield Jury: No Decision After 8 Days
- August 19, 2002: Westerfield Trial Jurors Back To Work
- August 16, 2002: Jury Goes Home; Asks For More Evidence
- August 15, 2002: Day Six Of Deliberations Offers No Verdict
- August 15, 2002: Jurors Continue Poring Through Evidence
- August 14, 2002: Westerfield Jury Into Fifth Day
- August 13, 2002: Westerfield Jury: Four Days, No Decision
- August 13, 2002: Judge Denounces Talk Show 'Idiots'
- August 13, 2002: Jury Asks For Westerfield Interview
- August 13, 2002: No Decision From Westerfield Jury
- August 12, 2002: More Westerfield Search Warrant Affidavits Released
- August 12, 2002: Westerfield Jury Resumes Deliberations
- August 9, 2002: Westerfield Jury Goes Home After Half-Day
- August 8, 2002: Westerfield's Fate In Jury's Hands
- August 8, 2002: Radio Producer Kicked Out Of Westerfield Trial
- August 8, 2002: Westerfield Trial Close To Finishing
- August 7, 2002: Feldman Decries 'Sinister Spin'
- August 7, 2002: Dusek: Westerfield 'Guilty Of Ultimate Evil'
- August 6, 2002: Dusek: Westerfield 'Guilty To The Core'
- August 6, 2002: Dusek: The Case Is Simple
- August 2, 2002: Westerfield Trial Close To Wrapping Up
- August 2, 2002: Westerfield Defense Set To Rest Case Tuesday
- August 1, 2002: Another Entomologist Takes Stand In Westerfield Trial
- July 31, 2002: Westerfield Trial: Bug Expert Challenges Defense
- July 30, 2002: Westerfield Jury May Be Sequestered
- July 29, 2002: Westerfield Trial Could Last Into Next Week
- July 25, 2002: Expert: Danielle Had Been Dead 4-6 Weeks
- July 25, 2002: Mudd Threatens To Kick Cameras From Courtroom
- July 25, 2002: Forensic Expert Counters Defense Bug Evidence
- July 24, 2002: Westerfield's Son Takes Stand
- July 24, 2002: Judge Mudd Gives Media Tongue-Lashing
- July 23, 2002: Westerfield Trial Takes Another Day Off
- July 22, 2002: Another Bug Expert Testifies In Westerfield Trial
- July 22, 2002: Westerfield Trial Resumes After 11-Day Break
- July 19, 2002: Runnion Murder Could Impact Westerfield Jury
- July 12, 2002: Motion To Unseal More Affidavits Denied
- July 12, 2002: Woman Loses Job Over Westerfield Trial
- July 11, 2002: Westerfield: Desert A 'Great Place To Dump A Body'
- July 10, 2002: Bug Expert Raises Questions About When Danielle Died
- July 10, 2002: Westerfield's Former Girlfriend Takes Stand
- July 10, 2002: Prosecution Presents New Fiber Evidence
- July 9, 2002: Questions Raised About Who Saw What, And When
- July 8, 2002: Witnesses: Westerfield, Van Dam Danced Together
- July 8, 2002: Witness: Brenda 'Dirty Danced' With Westerfield
- July 3, 2002: Westerfield Trial Focuses On Porn, Again
- July 3, 2002: Computer Porn Associated With Westerfield's Son
- July 3, 2002: Prosecution Wraps Up, For Now
- July 2, 2002: Dog Handler 'Bursting With Pride' After Westerfield Arrest
- July 1, 2002: Prosecution Asks For One More Witness
- June 28, 2002: Westerfield Defense Concerned Over Being 'Ambushed'
- June 27, 2002: Closed-Door Hearing Held In Westerfield Trial
- June 26, 2002: Porn, Motor Home Focus Of Westerfield Trial
- June 26, 2002: Jurors Tour Westerfield Motor Home
- June 26, 2002: Westerfield Computer Had 85 Questionable Images
- June 26, 2002: Porn Evidence Introduced In Westerfield Trial
- June 25, 2002: Criminalist: Fibers Connect Westerfield, Danielle
- June 25, 2002: Damon Van Dam Kicked Out Of Courtroom
- June 25, 2002: Day 12: Danielle-Like Hairs Found
- June 24, 2002: Criminalist: Blond Hairs On Westerfield Bed Sheets
- June 24, 2002: Hair Like Danielle's Found In Westerfield Bed Sheets
- June 21, 2002: DNA Expert: Danielle's Blood Found In RV
- June 20, 2002: DNA Expert: Danielle's Blood In Westerfield RV, Jacket
- June 20, 2002: Specialist: Danielle's Prints In Westerfield Motor Home
- June 19, 2002: Laundry, Videotapes, Lubricant Seized From Westerfield Home
- June 19, 2002: Trial Focuses On Evidence Collected By Police
- June 18, 2002: Forensics Specialist Collected Hairs, Necklace
- June 18, 2002: Dry Cleaners: Westerfield Distant, Rushed
- June 14, 2002: Judge Tries To Inject Levity Into Westerfield Trial
- June 14, 2002: Park Rangers: Westerfield Overpaid, Shows Wallet
- June 12, 2002: Westerfield Interview Heard; Neighbor Says Blinds Shut
- June 12, 2002: Westerfield Trial: KGTV Reporter Takes Stand
- June 11, 2002: Van Dam Friends Take Stand; Westerfield 'Creepy'
- June 7, 2002: Westerfield Trial Focuses On Van Dam Lifestyle
- June 6, 2002: Day 3: Brenda Van Dam, Dad's Bar
- June 6, 2002: Brenda Van Dam Testifies In Westerfield Trial
- June 6, 2002: Day 2: Damon Van Dam, Autopsy Photos
- June 5, 2002: Damon Van Dam Takes Witness Stand
- June 5, 2002: Cases Outlined In Westerfield Trial
- June 4, 2002: Westerfield Trial Starts; Witnesses Take Stand
- June 3, 2002: Westerfield Trial Set To Get Under Way
- May 31, 2002: Westerfield Trial Jury Selection Complete
- May 31, 2002: Westerfield Trial Scheduled To Start Tuesday
- May 30, 2002: Jury Selection In Westerfield Trial Enters Third Day
- May 28, 2002: Jury Selection Continues In Westerfield Trial
- May 20, 2002: Experts Question Speed Of Westerfield Trial
- May 17, 2002: Court To Interview 262 Potential Jurors
- May 17, 2002: Westerfield Jury Selection Under Way
- May 16, 2002: Westerfield Jury Selection Set To Begin
- May 16, 2002: Westerfield Trial Jury Questionnaire
- May 15, 2002: Judge May Make Rulings In Westerfield Case
- May 13, 2002: Westerfield Pre-Trial Still Closed
- May 10, 2002: Westerfield Trial: Pretrial Motions Remain Closed
- May 8, 2002: Reporters Called In Westerfield Trial
Copyright 2007 by 10News.com. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.





